In various fields, behavioural agents have played an influential role in shaping subfields pertaining to cognitive biases and hedonism. Challenging the traditional models and theories in economics and finance, behavioural economics integrates insights from psychology and economics, rejecting the notion of perfect rationality; expanding the scope of behavioural theories and deviating from established economic paradigms. However, an equivocal and apparent question conquers the battle - should behavioural agents be incorporated to reformulate economic models to sustain practicalism?
In the 1950s when the cognitive revolution was gaining traction, the ripple effect of cognitive psychology extended its influence to shed the light of behaviour agents on rational economic models and the foundational structures of microeconomic theories. This transformation gave rise to a series of groundbreaking theories, including Endowment Theory, Nudge Theory, and Behavioural Finance. These theories brought human behaviour to the forefront of economic analysis and led to a systematic departure from the traditional bounds of rationality in economic modelling.
The advent of behavioural economics could not have come at a more opportune time. In a rapidly evolving world, characterized by complex and unpredictable economic interactions, there is an increasing need for economic models that reflect real-world behaviour. Incorporating behavioural agents into economic models offers several advantages that address this pressing need. Traditional economic models that rely on the concept of perfect rationality often fall short when applied to real-world situations. People do not always make decisions based on a careful analysis of costs and benefits. However, behavioural economics, by acknowledging the role of biases and emotions, provides a more realistic framework for understanding. While behavioural finance has shed light on the limitations of traditional financial models and the presence of market inefficiencies, its knowledge is invaluable for investors and financial institutions, enabling them to make more informed decisions and adapt to changing market conditions. In the realm of business and investment, recognizing the impact of cognitive biases and emotions on decision-making is crucial for effective risk management. Incorporating behavioural insights into risk assessment can lead to more accurate predictions and better strategies for mitigating risks.
While the incorporation of behavioural agents into economic models presents numerous advantages, it's important to acknowledge that it is not a one-size-fits-all solution. There is a balance to be struck between the insights offered by behavioural economics and the simplifications required for tractable economic models. Moreover, the practicality of these models depends on their intended application.
Given the uncertainty in reflexes of individuals in the same situation, inculcating such pivot points might actually distort established gnomes and defeat the equilibrium of the field. It would create an additional layer of complexity due to the diverse interdisciplinary landscape of psychology, sociology, anthropology and much more. However consequential it might be, the lack of it not being a mainstream field subdues its overall presence in the purview of the study.
For instance, credit card companies have sentimentally and tactically deployed various strategies to increase the spending of users. One such strategy involves separating the pleasure of buying from the pain of paying. By leveraging the opportunity for users to make deferred payments, they increased their spending and tolled their future income. Such behavioural traits are instances of a shift from standardized economic paradigms and thus depicts irrationality of thoughts.
In real estate negotiations, the initial listing price often serves as an anchor that heavily influences the final sale price. Research has shown that buyers tend to base their offers on the listed price, even if it's significantly higher than market value. Real estate agents leverage this psychological bias to their advantage when pricing properties.
Behavioural economics has examined how loss aversion influences investor behaviour. When stock markets experience a sharp decline, many investors panic and sell their assets to avoid further losses. This behaviour is driven by the fear of losing money, even if a long-term perspective might suggest a different course of action.
Ongoing developments are revealing a profound shift in economic thinking as the principles of behavioural economics merge with traditional economic theories. Economists are recognizing the need to incorporate behavioural insights to counteract suboptimal decision-making, driven by the realization that bounded rationality is a rudimentary aspect of human behaviour. Furthermore, the intersection with neuroeconomics adds a biological dimension, shedding light on the underlying psychological mechanisms that influence decision-making.
In conclusion, the development of behavioural economics marked a pivotal moment in economic thought. The inclusion of behavioural agents in economic models has expanded our understanding of human decision-making, brought realism to economic analysis, and improved the design of policies and financial strategies. While the question of whether to incorporate behavioural agents remains, the answer increasingly seems to be in the affirmative. In an ever-changing world where human behaviour is far from being perfectly rational, will the inclusion of behavioural elements subdue the rigid principle models of economics and emerge as an unfiltered field, guided by instincts? Or, will its exclusion hinder the rationale of anticipated situations and lead practicalism into the abyss of rigid monopolistic theories?
St. Xavier’s College (Autonomous), Kolkata is an institution that transforms lives. It has always strived to nurture and consolidate the skills and calibre of its students to help them prevail with fervour and spirit, teaching them to break paradigms, aspire higher, and raise the bar each time.